FuelEU Maritime: Proposed Modification for the Non-Compliance Penalty Calculation

The European Union (EU) has implemented a tougher than IMO emission intensity indicator requirement for shipping. Under the FuelEU Maritime regulations a penalty applies where vessels are non-compliant to set greenhouse gas emission limits. In this Policy Briefing we outline why the penalty calculation is problematic – that it introduces distortions and undermines regulation objectives.

This policy briefing argues that:

  • The current formula calculates a penalty that is weaker for higher emitters, causes unequal treatment for fleets with the same level of non-compliance balance, and complicates the pooling mechanism.
  • Proposed modification would be to replace the Actual GHG Intensity with the Target GHG Intensity in the penalty payment calculation.
  • For the UK Government, in the expected fuel standard consultation and implementation, we recommend that such distorting effects are avoided rather than harmonising with the EU.

This policy briefing is based on the research and policy expertise of Professor Dongping Song, and Dr Claire Copeland.

IMO Short-term Measures: A Review of the Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII)

The Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) is one of the short-term measures introduced by the International Maritime Organization (IMO) to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from shipping. This policy brief reviews the measure and provides improvement recommendations, focusing on how emission standards at sea and at port should be dealt with.

Key Highlights:

  • CII is currently insufficient for capturing emissions accurately at sea and at port and incentivising emission reduction
  • A range of revision options could be considered such as excluding port emissions, adjustments for time at port, or separate metrics for at sea and at port
  • Other areas that could be considered include allowance for actual cargo, well- to-wake emissions, and pilot fuel

Recommended revision for CII is to use separate metrics for at sea and at port emissions.

This policy briefing is based on research undertaken by Dr Ioannis Moutzouris, Dr Yao Shi, and Dr Claire Copeland.

Hydrogen jet flame stabilisation mechanism for square and rectangular openings: Internal flame retention

“Abstract

Hydrogen is stored at high pressure making discharge a safety concern, including flame stability issue. Previous studies were focused on circular nozzles. However, actual incidents are more likely to involve slit-shaped openings. The experiments on hydrogen release from non-circular openings were conducted for nozzle cross-sectional areas equal to circular orifices of diameters 0.5, 0.6, 0.8 mm, with aspect ratios for rectangular orifices 1, 2, 4, 6, 8. For rectangular nozzles, expansion waves are generated from the corners in addition to those originating from the nozzle lip. These waves interfere causing an “axis-switching” phenomenon and formation of octagonal Mach disk, producing jet with wider velocity boundary, thus greater air entrainment and consequently 10–30 % shorter flame length. The lift-off length for rectangular openings, i.e. 10-15 mm was approximately half that of circular nozzles. The experimental and numerical study of non-combusting jet shed light on the flame stabilisation mechanism for rectangular nozzles identified as internal flame retention, i.e. anchoring the flame base at low-velocity region at the root of the cross-shaped velocity and hydrogen concentration distributions.”

 

Keiji Takeno, Makoto Asahara, Koichi Kajino, Ito, D., Mizuno, Y., Volodymyr Shentsov, Kazemi, M., Makarov, D. and Vladimir Molkov (2025). Hydrogen jet flame stabilisation mechanism for square and rectangular openings: Internal flame retention. International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 202, pp.152934–152934. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2025.152934.

The full report is accessible via: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2025.152934

 

For related publications please see Resources – UK National Clean Maritime Research Hub

Scheduling heterogeneous yard cranes for port decarbonization: power constraints, crane interference, and safety distances

“Abstract

Yard equipment upgrades are vital for port decarbonization, yet the coexistence of legacy and new yard cranes creates challenges in coordinating operations and allocating limited electrical power. This paper studies the integrated container allocation and conflict-free scheduling of multiple yard crane types, including slipline rail-mounted gantry crane (RMG), hybrid diesel-electric RMG, cable rubber-tyred gantry crane (RTG), and diesel-powered RTG, under power capacity, interference, and safety-distance constraints. We propose a mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) model that minimizes energy cost, carbon penalty, and makespan penalty. Because general-purpose solvers struggle with large instances, we develop a tailored logic-based Benders decomposition (TLBBD) algorithm with several enhancement strategies. Numerical experiments based on data from a real port demonstrate that TLBBD significantly outperforms Gurobi, an existing LBBD method, and real-world scheduling schemes, obtaining optimal or near-optimal solutions within 15 minutes for instances with five cranes and 100 containers. Sensitivity analyses on cable RTG cable length, yard crane layout, and carbon tax further illustrate the practical applicability of the proposed approach.”

 

Liu, B., Wang, F., Sheng, D., Zhang, X., Zheng, J. and Song, D. (2026). Scheduling heterogeneous yard cranes for port decarbonization: power constraints, crane interference, and safety distances. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review, 206, p.104581. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tre.2025.104581.

The full report is accessible via: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tre.2025.104581

For related publications, please see Resources – UK National Clean Maritime Research Hub

Policy Bulletin 007: CO2 Emission Reduction Technologies for Shipping

Maritime policy bulletin 007 covers CO2 emission reduction technologies for shipping.

In recent years maritime shipping has emitted approx. one gigatonne of carbon dioxide (CO2) per annum. Based on current trends this is projected to increase 150-250% by 2050, but the International Maritime Organisation has set targets of 30% reduction by 2030 and net-zero by 2050.

This work reviewed the potential for different emission reduction technologies to reach those targets.

This bulletin is based on a recent publication by Dr Sina Fadaie,  Professor Jean-Baptiste R. G. Souppez and Professor Patricia Thornley titled A systematic review of technologies, measures, and CO2 emission reduction potential for maritime transport decarbonisation.

To download the full policy bulletin, please click the download button above.

To read other bulletins, please see: Resources – UK National Clean Maritime Research Hub

Advancing maritime decarbonisation: Design and optimisation of ammonia-fuelled propulsion systems

“Abstract

Innovative marine propulsion systems play a pivotal role for decarbonising global maritime transportation. This study investigated an ammonia-fuelled hybrid powertrain system that integrates ammonia internal combustion engines with a battery energy storage system for a large containership, which were based on the credible and validated physical engine and battery models and real operation profiles of the case ship. A multi-objective optimisation framework based on the Non-Dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm II (NSGA-II) is developed for component sizing and selection. In parallel, a rule-based Energy Management Strategy (EMS) is employed to optimize power distribution and improve operational efficiency. The proposed hybrid configuration is benchmarked against a real-world powertrain system powered by heavy fuel oil engines and a scenario powertrain solely powered by the same type of ammonia engines. The case study on the representative containership demonstrates that the ammonia-fuelled propulsion system has significantly lower carbon emissions than the conventional propulsion system, which achieves a 79.36 % reduction in CO2 emissions. The hybrid ammonia-fuelled powertrain system has further 0.15 % CO2 emission reductions with an Energy Efficiency Existing Ship Index (EEXI) of 0.8085 gCO2/(t∗nmi). Nevertheless, fuel costs account for over 86 % of lifecycle expenditure, and high ammonia genset prices increase Capital Expenditure (CAPEX), resulting in higher overall costs of the ammonia-fuelled propulsion systems. These results indicate that ammonia as a marine fuel offers substantial decarbonisation potential and its economic feasibility depends on future ammonia cost reductions and optimal marine propulsion system design.”

 

Zhang, Y., Chen, P., Wu, D., Hao, X., Yang, T. and Cairns, A. (2025a). Advancing maritime decarbonisation: Design and optimisation of ammonia-fuelled propulsion systems. Journal of Cleaner Production, 535, p.147145. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2025.147145.

The full report is accessible via: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2025.147145

For related publications please see Resources – UK National Clean Maritime Research Hub

High efficiency fuel agnostic split cycle engine optimisation

“Abstract

Freight transport contributes 8 % of GHG emissions and requires propulsion systems that deliver both sustainability and high efficiency. This study introduces a novel system-level approach that links experimental data to modelling of a recuperated split cycle engine (RSCE) to identify a fuel-agnostic, high-efficiency pathway. The RSCE separates compression and expansion, enabling independent optimisation, intracycle heat recovery and combustion processes beyond the limits of conventional engines. While previous RSCE studies have demonstrated potential, they have typically focused on partial subsystems or idealised conditions, leaving key aspects of full-cycle thermodynamics underexplored. This work addresses those gaps by linking thermo-fluidic modelling with experimental results from a single-cylinder research engine (ESRE), representing the recuperation and expansion stages. Compression, recuperation, and expansion processes are analysed and integrated with AspenTech and Chemkin-Pro multizone simulations. Parameter studies evaluate the degree of isothermal compression (C), recuperator effectiveness (RE), expansion cylinder insulation, and compression to expansion volume ratios (CR:ER). Net system indicated efficiencies (ηsys,indicated) of up to 57 % are achieved under trade-off conditions (C = 0.4–0.5, RE = 0.85, CR:ER = 1:1.6–1.82), while maintaining initial temperatures high enough to enable autoignition, with peak temperature below the ≈2200 K thermal NOx rapid formation. A comparative analysis of hydrogen and methane fuelling shows similar ηsys values to diesel, demonstrating the architecture’s fuel flexibility. These results provide a robust reference for future clean engine development by demonstrating the feasibility of RSCE architectures to exceed conventional efficiency limits and offering a validated modelling platform readily expandable to future sustainable propulsion strategies.”

 

Wylie, E., Panesar, A. and Morgan, R. (2025). High efficiency fuel agnostic split cycle engine optimisation. Energy, 340, p.139158. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2025.139158.

The full report is accessible via: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2025.139158

 

For related publications please see Resources – UK National Clean Maritime Research Hub

A systematic review of technologies, measures, and CO2 emission reduction potential for maritime transport decarbonisation

“Abstract

The maritime shipping sector is a significant contributor to global carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions, accounting for approximately 2.7%-3% of global emissions. In response, the International Maritime Organization (IMO) has set ambitious targets: a 30% reduction in emissions by 2030, 80% by 2040, and net-zero by 2050, relative to 2008 levels. Meeting these goals requires a comprehensive understanding of the full range of viable decarbonisation measures. Therefore, this study conducts a systematic review of maritime decarbonisation measures, applying the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) methodology. Unlike previous studies, this paper not only provides an updated overview of CO2 reduction measures but also maps them to specific vessel types based on data reported in the literature. Furthermore, the findings are compared with literature to highlight shifts in mitigation potential. A case study is also included to schematically demonstrate how these measures can be applied in practice. Following a rigorous analysis: (i) thirty-two individual CO2 mitigation measures were identified and classified into six categories, (ii) alternative fuels shown the highest long-term potential (5%–100% CO2 emission reduction), whereas hull design improvements show the lowest (1%–20%), (iii) the wide disparity in reported abatement values is attributed to inconsistent system boundaries, variability in fuel origin, partial-blend scenarios, and differing assumptions across studies, (iv) combinations of measures provide the most practical and realistic pathway to phased emissions reduction. These findings are expected to assist decision-makers in selecting effective, context-appropriate strategies to support global maritime decarbonisation and ensure long-term sectoral sustainability.”

 

Fadaie, S., Thornley, P. and Souppez, J.-B. (2025). A systematic review of technologies, measures, and CO2 emission reduction potential for maritime transport decarbonisation. Advances in Applied Energy, p.100255. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.adapen.2025.100255.

The full report is accessible via: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.adapen.2025.100255

For related publications, please see Resources – UK National Clean Maritime Research Hub

Experimental study of liquid ammonia injection timing in rapeseed methyl ester dual injection engine

“Abstract

Ammonia, a promising carbon-free fuel, offers practical advantages over hydrogen, such as liquid-phase storage, making it suitable for direct use in compression ignition engines. As a hydrogen carrier, ammonia has the potential to decarbonise internal combustion engines. However, its widespread adoption faces challenges, including high emissions of unburned ammonia and other pollutants. This study examines the effect of liquid injection timing of ammonia on the combustion, performance, and emissions of a rapeseed methyl ester (RME) dual-fuel compression ignition engine. Experiments were carried out on a single-cylinder diesel engine equipped with dual high-pressure injectors to evaluate ammonia injection timings between −25 and −7 CAD bTDC using a GDI injector. The results show that overlapping ammonia injection with RME significantly enhanced engine performance, with the optimal SOI of −17 CAD for both fuels achieving the highest indicated efficiency of 37.8 %. Moreover, injecting ammonia a few CADs after the RME effectively minimised emissions. Therefore, the lowest NH3 emission of 453 ppm was recorded at SOI of −14 CAD. However, delaying the SOI of ammonia further to −7 CAD led to a rise in CO, N2O, and PM emissions due to incomplete combustion of RME caused by liquid ammonia injection.”

 

Nadimi, E., Przybyla, G., Wu, D. and Adamczyk, W. (2025). Experimental study of liquid ammonia injection timing in rapeseed methyl ester dual injection engine. Energy, 335, p.137919. doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2025.137919.

The full report is accessible via: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2025.137919

For related publications, please see Resources – UK National Clean Maritime Research Hub

Performance, emissions, and lubricant oil analysis of a marine diesel engine powered by raw Schizochytrium sp. and its blends

“Abstract

Microalgae oil (MAO), a third-generation biofuel, can support global transportation fuel demand as a fossil fuel substitute. Schizochytrium sp. MAO is particularly promising for direct use in compression ignition (CI) engines, especially in the marine sector, due to its adaptability and high oil yield. This study investigated the performance, emissions, and optimization of a single-cylinder marine diesel engine operating on MAO and MAO/diesel oil (DO) blends. The results show that MAO significantly reduced nitrogen oxide (NOx) and carbon monoxide (CO) emissions by up to 59%, despite its higher viscosity and density and its lower heating value compared with DO. Brake-specific fuel consumption (BSFC) increased by 46%, but brake power and brake thermal efficiency (BTE) decreased by up to 40% and 26%, respectively. After 30 h of operation, the lubricant oil (LO) in MAO-fueled engines contained 15% less Zn, 19% less P, and 16% less Ca than that in DO-fueled engines.”

 

Debnath, Victor, Hassan Mohammadsami Attar, Ebrahim Nadimi, and Dawei Wu. “Performance, emissions, and lubricant oil analysis of a marine diesel engine powered by raw Schizochytrium sp. and its blends.” Biofuels, Bioproducts and Biorefining (2025).

The full report is accessible via: https://doi.org/10.1002/bbb.70058

For related publications please see Resources – UK National Clean Maritime Research Hub